Pumpkin Mac n Cheese with Amaretti Crust

Pumpkin Mac n Cheese with Amaretti Crust

With Halloween quickly approaching I have had pumpkins on my mind a lot! Pumpkin has to be one of my favourite ingredients at this time of year and there are just so many amazing dishes that can be made with it that it is sometimes difficult to decided which ones to go with. Do you go with a tried and true recipe like this pumpkin ravioli in sage and browned butter sauce or do you try something new? Speaking of the pumpkin ravioli, I recently came across the idea of adding crumbled amaretti cookies to it and I was immediately entranced by it! The ravioli is normally a savoury dish and I really liked the sound of adding the sweet and almond-y amaretti cookies to it and I knew that I would have to try the flavour combo out! I had also just been itching to try a pumpkin macaroni and cheese and I decided to combine the two ideas into one.

I could have gone one of two ways with the pumpkin mac n cheese by using either pumpkin puree or with roasted cubes of pumpkin. Since I liked the idea of nice big chunks of pumpkin in the mac and cheese I went that route, though I did end up mashing some of the roasted pumpkin cubes before mixing it into the pasta to get the best of both worlds. The base of macaroni and cheese is very often a bechamel sauce that the cheese is melted into. A bechamel sauce is made by cooking butter, mixing in some flour and then adding a liquid before letting it simmer until it thickens. The trick to a good bechamel sauce is to let the flour cook in the butter before adding the liquid and this helps to ensure that the sauce does not have a floury taste. Another thing that you can do to give your bechamel some extra flavour is to brown the butter before adding the flour and I took the opportunity to add a healthy amount of sage to the butter as it browned. Of course the most important part of macaroni and cheese is the cheese and this time I went with a combination of gruyere and fontina which are nice and melty and some parmigiano reggiano which is just full of flavour. Finally, I fit the amaretti cookie crumbs in by topping the mac and cheese with them.

This recipe is pretty straight forward and easy but it does require a bit of time as you have to roast the pumpkin and then bake the macaroni and cheese. I could barely contain myself through all of the roasting and the baking and then waiting for it too cool down seemed like an eternity but I was rewarded when I finally got to dig in. The pumpkin macaroni and cheese with amaretti crumb topping was and magnificent marriage of sweet and savoury! You really cannot go wrong with pasta covered in a melted cheese sauce and the almost sweet pumpkin went so well with all of that savoury cheese! The pumpkin and sage flavour combo was once again a complete winner and the crumbled amaretti cookies were indeed the highlight of the dish! I would say that the key to the amaretti cookies is to not use too much as it was really nice to hit small pockets of the crunchy sweet almond flavoured bits every once in a while. I will definitely be making this again and now I am looking forward to eating the leftovers for lunch this week!

Note: Any winter squash such as a butternut squash or kabocha would also work beautifully in this macaroni and cheese as a substitute for the pumpkin.

Pumpkin Mac n Cheese with Amaretti Crust

Pumpkin Mac n Cheese with Amaretti Crust

A creamy mac and cheese with roasted pumpkin, sage, plenty of cheese and an amaretti crumb topping.

Servings: makes 4-8 servings

Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour 20 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Printable Recipe
  • 1 pound of pumpkin/squash, peeled, seeded and cut into 1 inch cubes
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • salt and pepper
  • 10 ounces pasta, your choice
  • 4 tablespoons butter
  • 2 tablespoons sage, thinly sliced
  • 4 tablespoons flour
  • 2 cups milk
  • 1 pinch nutmeg
  • 1 teaspoon dijon mustard
  • 2 cups cheese, shredded - I used a combo of gruyere, fontina and parmigiano reggiano (parmesan)
  • 1/2 cup amaretti cookies, crumbled
  1. Toss the pumpkin with the olive oil and season with salt and pepper.
  2. Roast the pumpkin in a preheated 350F oven until tender, about 30-40 minutes and set aside.
  3. Cook the pasta as directed.
  4. Melt the butter in a saucepan over medium heat add the sage and cook until the butter is bubbling and it has turned golden brown.
  5. Mix in the flour and let simmer until it returns to a light golden brown.
  6. Add the milk, nutmeg, mustard and cheese and simmer until it thickens and the cheese has melted.
  7. Mix the pumpkin, pasta and cheese sauce and pour into a baking dish topping it with the amaretti cookie crumbs.
  8. Bake in a preheated 350F oven until golden brown on the top and bubbling on the sides, about 30-40 minutes.

Similar Recipes:
Roasted Butternut Squash Lasagna
Butternut Squash and Parmesan Pasta with Sage
Pumpkin and Cream Cheese Ravioli in Sage and Butter Sauce
Pumpkin Gnocchi in a Brown Butter and Sage Sauce
Beer Mac n Cheese Soup


Cara said...

I bet that touch of sweet from the cookies is heavenly :)

Pam said...

Oh wow Kevin. That looks so rich, decadent, and delicious. You are so creative in the kitchen.

Xiaolu @ 6 Bittersweets said...

Great combination of flavors! I'd love to try this :)

Gone-ta-pott said...

Oh my goodness this recipe is just heavenly. The pictures are beautiful too.

Georgia | The Comfort of Cooking said...

Wow, what a lovely use for pumpkin! I would have never thought of something so creative. It looks absolutely delicious and like something I should definitely try this season, mac 'n cheese being one of my favorite fall comfort foods. Thank you for sharing!

bellini said...

I have a cooking pumpkin sitting on my deck just waiting for that special meal and its moment to shine. I may have just found its purpose Kevin.

FabFrugalFood said...

Wow! What a fabulous idea - pumpkin in mac and cheese - I'll bet this makes the dish so flavorful!


Lost&Found said...

Love the idea to add mustard! can't wait to try this!

Rosa's Yummy Yums said...

Scrumptious! The addition of amaretti is really interesting.



What A Dish! said...

I've made a pumpkin mac and cheese before but yours looks way better and more creative! Love the photo too.

Joanne said...

Just so we're clear...I am THISCLOSE to proposing to you right now. I love the idea of that crust against the cheesy macaroni...amazing.

warmvanillasugar said...

The crust in this is a really great touch. I like the idea as opposed to adding bread crumbs. Yum!

Ben said...

When it comes to pumpkin, I always try something new. This mac n cheese looks so good!

Jan said...

Love it! Love the cookie crumb top too!
Ps: This is in my newspaper today :)

judge said...

That sounds Delish! The crust is pure genius!

Julia said...

How random, I posted a pumpkin mac and cheese recipe yesterday too! So I know, from experience, it's just DELICIOUS! An amaretti crust, oh wow, that sounds DELIGHTFUL!!!!!

John said...

Brilliant! I have been gifted with a bounty of pumpkins by a gardening neighbor. Can't wait to try this out!

matteo/dentro la pentola said...

truly season flavoured !

Deb said...

An irresistible version of Mac n Cheese. The Amaretti topping coupled with the roasted squash is sumptuous! Add lots of cheese too!

Kathryn said...

Uh-oh, two of my favorite comfort dishes, mac-&-cheese and pumpkin ravioli with browned butter and sage, just had a love child. I'm doomed.

Russell at Chasing Delicious said...

Yum! What a recipe! What a lovely combination of flavors.

Anonymous said...

Looks delicious!

We're going to try this out on Monday, one thing we're not sure about though.

Does the recipe take both Squash and Pumpkin? Or is it a choice between the two? The recipe mentions squash at the start but doesn't later on.

Deb said...

Amazing Mac n Cheese recipe! I doubled the recipe so I would have enough for a party today, dinner last night and some to share with my mom. I was not disappointed, comforting and marvelous, great recipe!

Kevin said...

Anonymous: You can use pumpkin or squash. I will clean up the recipes.

Lucy said...

Ok, I just made this with delicata squash instead of pumpkin. It was delicious, a big hit with the family. Thanks for the recipe!

theamericaine.blogspot.com said...

This sounds perfect for fall and like it would add a wonderful element to mac n cheese.

Tiffany said...

Delicious! I also tried the recipe with squash instead of pumpkin (I used butternut squash). The sweetness from the cookies really adds that extra savory component to the final product. I will make this again, closer to the holidays.

zi4e said...

Страхотни рецепти!

Carlo/Carlo At Your Service Productions said...

This sounds wonderful.

I would have NEVER thought to add pumpkin to mac'n cheese. Now I've got to try it. Yummers! This is in my ZipList and I will make it real soon.


Michelle Lee said...

That look soo good Kevin! I love Mac N Cheese!

Anonymous said...

Wow this sounds yummy!! Is the idea to have chunks of pumpkin/squash (assuming you mean winter squash?) or is it mashed into the sauce?

Kevin said...

Anonymous: Yes most winter squashes will work, you peel, cube them, them roast them and then add the chunks to the mac n cheese.

Anonymous said...

Where do you get the amaretti cookies?

Kevin Lynch said...

Anonymous: Amaretti cookies can be found in the cookie section of some grocery stores or in import grocery stores or Italian shops like bakeries, delis, cafes etc.

Rakshanda Anderson said...

That is very innovative - would have never thought of adding pumpkin but it looks delicious and will definitely have a go. Being vegan I would substitute milk with coconut milk and use vegan cheese - thank you Kevin

Post a Comment